« Contentment vs. Complacency | Main | Still kicking »
December 14, 2005
The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe
Categories: Pictures
Sarah was working late Monday so I went and saw the Narnia movie by myself. I drove to the Regal off 485; it's a little nicer theatre than we have here in Rock Hill and I have that Regal club card where you get points for seeing movies. It's good to be in the club, since I got a free popcorn coupon after buying my ticket Monday.
I read and enjoyed the Narnia books very much when I was younger, but have not read them in a long time. I was looking forward to the movie a lot, just to see what would be done with the property, and to see how the movie "felt" compared to LotR.
I liked it, but didn't love it. 7 out of 10.
There are spoliers in the rest of the review.
I enjoyed the film very much up until the "war". The actors who played the children were very good (Lucy and Edmund especially). The faun and other creatures were well done. The White Witch was meanacing, yet seductive (in a PG appropriate way). The film made it clear why Edumund would have betrayed the other children. The religious overtones were there, of course, but not in an obnoxious way. The story is a very nice retelling of the Passion and the essence of Christ's sacrifice.
I have a hard time putting my finger on why I did not enjoy the movie more, but it had something to do with Peter. Not with the actor, or even the character, really. I think I had my suspension of disbelief damaged a bit by the fact that these four children go from being just ordinary kids to great warriors and leaders of Narnia in about 36 hours. There was an attempt to show Peter's reluctance of taking up the leadership mantle, to approach the difficulty even a prophesized king would have taking a life for the first time, but that never really worked for me. Maybe it was the "clean your sword" comment from Aslan about a not-bloody sword (which I suppose was not bloody to keep the movie PG and kid friendly). If they would have held that scene a little longer, given us a shot of Peter wiping the blood of the foe from his blade with a look of sadness yet determination on his face, maybe things would have been fine for me, I don't know.
Maybe expecting character development from a two hour film that comes from a children's story is asking too much. Maybe it's the source material; the book probably just has the children assume their roles as Narnian royalty without batting an eyelash. Maybe that lack of character drama is why I have only read the Narnia books two or three times since that first time in the third grade and I have read Tolkien's stuff fifteen or twenty.
Good, yes. Definetly worth a viewing. A very good children's movie, but ultimately just and only that (for me at least).
Posted by Nakia at December 14, 2005 01:58 PM